David Karger
Jan 13, 2021

I have no idea; not my field. I do doubt that the paper was withdrawn purely for political reasons; while it may have *examined* for political reasons, I assume the withdrawal was for scientific flaws. If the other papers you mention have similar flaws, I assume they will soon be withdrawn based on attention being brought to those flaws by people who are unhappy with the current withdrawal. We'll see if they survive that scrutiny.

David Karger
David Karger

Written by David Karger

Professor of Computer Science at MIT CSAIL

Responses (1)